Recommendations for Congress: The Supreme Court Needs a Mandatory and Enforceable Code of Ethics
Congress has the power to enact a code of conduct (“ethics code”) for the Supreme Court under the Necessary and Proper Clause of the U.S. Constitution. The Necessary and Proper Clause permits Congress to create a binding and enforceable Supreme Court ethics code to define the “good behavior” that entitles a Justice to stay in office and to set standards that, if violated, could lead to impeachment.
THE JUDICIAL INVESTIGATION PANEL
- Congress should create a Judicial Investigation Panel (“the Panel”) of five federal judges tasked with receiving and screening complaints involving alleged misconduct by Supreme Court Justices including, but not limited to, a claimed need for recusal and receipt or nondisclosure of gifts.
- The Panel would report annually to the Court and Congress on its work and make such recommendations as it sees fit for revisions to the ethics code or the enforcement process.
- The Panel would refer to the Office of Inspector General (“OIG”) those complaints that it found to be colorable and not duplicative.
- The Panel would decide issues of ethical violations and recusal based on factual reports from the OIG.
THE OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL
- Congress should create an Office of the Inspector General for the Supreme Court that would investigate referrals from the Panel if the Panel determines that a complaint had colorable merit.
- The OIG would be required to investigate matters referred by the Panel (and no other matters). The OIG would be vested with authority to interview Justices and other witnesses, subpoena evidence, and prepare a report.
- The Chief Justice would have the sole power to appoint (for a four-year term), and to dismiss, the Supreme Court Inspector General, in consultation with Congressional leaders.
- If the OIG finds facts that could demonstrate an ethical or reporting violation, it must issue to the Panel, the Court, the Attorney General, Congress, and the public a report describing the referral from the Panel, its investigation, and its conclusions, without recommendations for discipline.
- The OIG must also provide the Chief Justice, Congress, and the public with an annual report on its activities.
DISCIPLINE FOR ETHICAL VIOLATIONS
- Disciplinary authority for ethical violations should vest in the first instance with the Panel, whose decisions would become final in 30 days if the Supreme Court takes no action.
- Disciplinary options should include public or private admonition or censure. Violations can also be referred to the Attorney General for civil or criminal prosecution or to Congress for impeachment.
RECUSAL
- In cases where a complaint is lodged that a Justice should recuse in a pending merits case, the Panel must review and refer potentially meritorious complaints promptly, and any investigations by the OIG should be concluded well in advance of oral argument.
- A Justice may decide to recuse on his or her own, but if the Justice does not recuse when presented with facts that could support recusal from the Inspector General, the Justice cannot judge his or her own case. The issue must be decided by the Judicial Panel, whose decisions become final in 30 days if the Court takes no action.
CONGRESS SHOULD ACT TO REFORM THE SUPREME COURT’S CODE OF CONDUCT TO HELP RESTORE THE PUBLIC’S FAITH IN OUR HIGHEST COURT