Committee Reports

FY25-26 Budget Impact on Children and Families

SUMMARY

The Council on Children sent a letter to Governor Kathy Hochul, NYS Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, and NYS Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins commenting on provisions in the FY 2025-26 New York State Executive Budget impacting children and families. The Council urged the governor and legislative leaders to address the following issues to help strengthen families experiencing poverty: creation and funding of a statewide supervised visitation program; increased salaries for Attorneys for Children; increased funding for the Office of Indigent Legal Services; cost of living increases for 18b assigned attorneys and AFC assigned counsel; creation of a Youth Justice Innovation Fund; and creation of the Child and Family Wellbeing Fund. “[W]hile we recognize and applaud the proposals addressing poverty of children and families throughout New York State that are included in the Executive Budget and the Senate and Assembly budget resolutions, there is more that must be done to support New York State’s children and families. We are concerned about the omissions in the FY25-26 Executive Budget that will result in lack of due process and obstacles preventing access to justice in the State’s Family Courts. Our lawmakers must address the issues described above to advance measures that prevent system involvement whenever possible, while ensuring due process when it cannot be avoided. We are concerned that the failure to adequately address these issues will perpetuate the problems of poverty and inequality in the New York City and State Family Courts, and the fair administration of justice.”

OUTCOME

These items were not included in the final FY 2026 NYS Budget

REPORT

By Email

Hon. Kathy Hochul
Governor of the State of New York
New York State Capitol Building
Albany, NY

Hon. Carl Heastie
Speaker
New York State Assembly
Legislative Office Building 932
Albany, NY 12248

Hon. Andrea Stewart-Cousins
Majority Leader
New York State Senate
Legislative Office Building 907
Albany, NY 12247

Re: FY 25-26 New York State Executive Budget

Dear Governor Hochul, Speaker Heastie, and Majority Leader Stewart-Cousins:

On behalf of the New York City Bar Association’s Council on Children,[1] we write regarding the proposals in the FY25-26 Executive Budget and related amendments that we believe will have a significant impact on children and families in New York State.

We urge the Legislature and the Governor to address the following issues to help strengthen families experiencing poverty.

I. We Urge the Creation and Funding of a Statewide Supervised Visitation Program

Regrettably absent from the FY25-26 executive budget is the establishment of a statewide supervised visitation program. As documented in the October 2024 update to the July 2023 Report from the Working Group on the Future of Supervised Visitation in New York State, there is a woeful lack of resources available to effectuate supervised visitation orders in custody/visitation cases in New York City, and elsewhere in the State.[2] Unfortunately, in New York City there are not enough individuals and organizations that provide these desperately-needed services, which keep children safe, reunite fractured families, and provide valuable information to courts regarding interactions between children and parents. Additionally, due to the shortage of free or low-cost visit supervision providers, many low-income families that litigate custody and visitation in New York City’s Family Courts and the Integrated Domestic Violence Parts of the Supreme Court find it cost prohibitive and/or impossible to exercise visits that the court has ordered.[3]

Moreover, the few providers that exist in New York City simply do not have the capacity and/or staff to meet the demand for their services. Based on the experience of practitioners on the Council, that limited capacity leads to unconscionably long waitlists for implementation of court-ordered supervised visits, with families in New York City routinely waiting six months to a year between a court’s entry of a supervised visitation order and the commencement of visits. Such enormous delays hinder efforts to normalize fractured parent-child relationships and hold up pending litigation, as courts await reports from providers so that they may make fully informed decisions regarding what restrictions, if any, to impose on a parent’s contact with a child.

Notably, there are two bills currently pending (A.65-A (AM Hevesi) and S.3938 (Sen. Hoylman-Sigal)) that would establish the supervised visitation program that New York so desperately needs. The distinction between these bills lies primarily between the agencies that each bill authorizes to administer the program. The Council on Children takes no position regarding whether the NYS Office of Children and Family Services should administer the initiative, as specified in the S.3938, or whether that responsibility should lie with the NYS Office of Victim Services, as directed in A.65-A. However, we note that the Senate one-house bill contains $6 million for supervised visitation that would be appropriated to the NYS Division of Criminal Justice Services and sub-allocated to the NYS Office of Court Administration. We oppose this administrative structure because neither agency is a social service agency. Further, unlike S.3938 or A.65-A, the language bills that accompany the budget do not delineate the essential elements of the program. We strongly urge the Legislature and the Governor to implement and adequately fund a statewide visitation program, as such programs not only protect children’s physical safety and emotional well-being, but also help families heal. To that end, we ask that $20 million be allocated for this Fund, that it should be administered through an appropriate social services agency, and that the budget language bills include the structure and essential elements of the program.

II. Increased Salaries for Attorneys for Children

In March 2023, this Council first wrote to sound an alarm regarding the unprecedented crisis of underfunding of Attorney for the Child (AFC) offices, which threatened the safety and well-being of the children who those offices serve. Unfortunately, these concerns remain relevant today, as the increased investments to AFC institutional providers that the State has made since then were insufficient to adequately and fairly fund the critical work that AFCs do on behalf of some of New York’s most vulnerable children.

This year, the New York State Court System has requested a 3% increase in funding for AFC offices, compared to a requested increase of 9.9% for court operations overall. Despite the critical nature of the services AFCs provide and the decades of underfunding for those offices, the judiciary is requesting a smaller increase for the AFC line than for other expenses.

To address this inequity, the judiciary budget request asserts that additional enhanced funding will also be distributed to the AFC providers through the UCS IV-E Fund for a total contractual increase of $9.6 million (9.2%).  However, our lawmakers should not rely on federal Title IV-E funding for this increase due to the precarious nature of federal funding at present. Instead, the final enacted budget should include in the Judiciary Budget a 10% increase in funding for the services provided by AFC offices.

III. Increased Funding for the Office of Indigent Legal Services

We oppose the proposed 2025 “Sweep” of Funds from the Indigent Legal Services Fund to the General Fund and call for increased funding for parent representation.

New York State established the Indigent Legal Services (ILS) Fund to assist New York City and other counties in providing legal representation to indigent persons in Criminal and Family Court cases who are unable to afford counsel. The entirety of the ILS Fund was intended to support ongoing efforts to improve the quality of public defense representation throughout the State. Although some improvements have occurred with respect to the representation of defendants in Criminal Court, there still is much work to be done to improve the quality of representation in Family Court. Thus, across the State, including in New York City, counties are struggling to fulfill their mandate to provide quality representation to Family Court litigants who are facing the most trying of circumstances, including the potential removal of their children due to allegations of child maltreatment, and restrictions on their custody of and visitation with their children. Moreover, low-income families and families of color, who are the majority of New Yorkers litigating in the State’s Family Courts, primarily bear the brunt of this failing.

Unfortunately, the FY25-26 Executive Budget poses an even greater threat to the counties’ ability to provide quality representation to Family Court litigants. The Governor proposes to transfer, or “sweep,” the $234 million of critical funding from the ILS Fund into the General Fund, with $120 million of that funding being transferred for unspecified purposes. Such a sweep would undermine the purpose of the ILS Fund, as the $120 million transferred for unspecified purposes would be vulnerable to raiding and thus diverted from that funding’s intended purpose. We vigorously oppose this proposal, which will place families and children who already are vulnerable at even greater risk of unnecessary family separation and foster care placement. We urge the Legislature to work with the Executive to reduce the proposed sweep, so that it is limited to only the $114 million explicitly intended to cover increased assigned counsel costs, as that is directly related to the purpose of the ILS Fund.

With respect to the Aid to Localities budget appropriations, the Executive Budget included $19.5 million for ILS to improve the quality of mandated representation of parents in Family Court matters. This is the same as the appropriation in last year’s final enacted budget. We urge the Governor and Legislature to include an additional $30.5 million in the FY25-26 budget, as called for by the Office of Indigent Legal Services, in order to address the crisis in Family Court representation. We also urge the Legislature and the Governor to include an additional $6 million to increase the rates paid to attorneys assigned pursuant to Article 18-b of the County Law, to the same level as federal defenders, as called for in the recent report of the NYS Senate Children and Families and Judiciary Committees.[4]

IV. Cost of Living Increases for the 18b Assigned Attorneys and AFC Assigned Counsel

Assembly Bill A.2682, introduced by Assembly Member Magnarelli, calls for amendments to the County and Judiciary Laws to provide much-needed annual cost of living increases for attorneys assigned pursuant to County Law § 18-B and Judiciary Law § 35 to represent indigent New Yorkers in criminal prosecutions and family court proceedings.[5] We urge you to incorporate these amendments into the budget, and to appropriate funding sufficient to effectuate this change. Such measures will represent an important step towards achieving fair and equitable compensation for assigned legal counsel, which will in turn benefit the thousands of New Yorkers who depend upon such legal services each year.

The assigned counsel panels cover cases in Family Court, Surrogate’s Court, Supreme Court, and Criminal Court, representing children and adults in complex cases where individuals stand to lose their liberty and/or relationships with family members. The attorneys representing these clients are certified after an extensive review and approval process, and often bring decades of experience to their cases. After 20 years, these assigned counsel finally received a critical increase in compensation in the 2024-2025 budget, so that their rate was commensurate with those paid to Federal Defenders in New York.  However, equity for these attorneys cannot be achieved unless their hourly compensation reflects annual cost of living increases recorded by the U.S. Secretary of Labor, and is the same wage adjustment mandated by the U.S. Criminal Justice Act for federal assigned counsel.[6] With cost of living increases rising another 2.5 percent this year, it is imperative that the state provide reasonable compensation to ensure quality representation for indigent New Yorkers.

V. The Creation of a Youth Justice Innovation Fund

Since the Raise the Age law was first implemented back in 2018, overall youth crime has consistently gone down, improving community safety and youth well-being while diverting young people away from the adult jails and prisons.

However, despite this significant progress, New York State has failed to fully deliver on its promise to fund community-based services and programs that provide alternatives to incarceration and reentry programs for young people. From 2019-2023, only a third of the money appropriated for youth justice under Raise the Age has been spent. That is why we are calling for a new funding pathway that allows community organizations to apply directly to the state for funding. This Youth Justice Innovation Fund would direct $50 million to community-based organizations to provide a continuum of services from prevention and early intervention, to alternatives to detention, placement and incarceration, to reentry services for youth aged 12 through 25, including in New York City.

The Youth Justice Innovation Fund (A.767 (A.M. Solages) and S.643 (Sen. Cleare)) would be administered by the NYS Division of Criminal Justice Services and would take $50 million of the $250 million appropriated every year for Raise the Age programs. The Senate one-house resolution includes funding for the Youth Justice Innovation Fund, and we urge the Legislature and the Governor to ensure that the final enacted budget includes language establishing the Youth Justice Innovation Fund to allow grant-making to community-based organizations in all counties, including New York City, along with an appropriation of $50M to create the fund.

VI. The Creation of the Child and Family Wellbeing Fund

Finally, we urge you to include the Child and Family Wellbeing Fund in the budget. The Fund, part of the Child and Family Wellbeing Program advanced by Assembly Member Hevesi (A.63-A) and Senator Brisport (S.6431), would direct state dollars to communities with the highest rates of Child Protective Services (CPS) contact and disproportionate impact on families of color, to fund community-led projects that strengthen families, reduce their vulnerability to CPS contact, and invest in supports that enhance family preservation, reunification, and healing. The Fund is a five-year pilot, serving 10 communities statewide, to help address the devastating correlation between poverty and child welfare system involvement.  We urge the Legislature and the Governor to provide appropriate funding to establish the Child and Family Wellbeing Fund, and to include language in the final enacted budget delineating the essential aspects of the program as described in A.63-A/S.6431.

In sum, while we recognize and applaud the proposals addressing poverty of children and families throughout New York State that are included in the Executive Budget and the Senate and Assembly budget resolutions, there is more that must be done to support New York State’s children and families. We are concerned about the omissions in the FY25-26 Executive Budget that will result in a lack of due process and obstacles preventing access to justice in the State’s Family Courts. Our lawmakers must address the issues described above to advance measures that prevent system involvement whenever possible, while ensuring due process when it cannot be avoided.  We are concerned that the failure to adequately address these issues will perpetuate the problems of poverty and inequality in the New York City and State Family Courts, and the fair administration of justice.

Sincerely,

Cathy Cramer, Chair
Council on Children

Footnotes

[1] The Council on Children is comprised of representatives of all the City Bar committees dealing with children, education, family, family court, juvenile justice, and the needs of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender youth. Also sitting on the Council are representatives of the child welfare, juvenile justice, and foster care communities, including attorneys representing parents and children.

[2] According to the Working Group’s report, 28 counties in New York State in 2024, up from 20 in 2023, lack any supervised visitation programming for families involved in custody/visitation litigation.  Report of the Working Group on the Future of Supervised Visitation in NYS (NYS Unified Court System Office of Justice Initiatives, July 2023, updated Oct. 2024).

[3] Unfortunately, it appears that the number of New York City residents struggling to afford basic necessities has risen dramatically in recent years. According to a new report from Columbia and the Robinhood Foundation, 1 in 4 New York City residents are living in poverty, and families do not have enough money for every day needs, such as housing and food. Further, that report showed that the poverty rate in New York City was nearly double the national average in 2023, and that in two years it had increased by seven percentage points. Poverty Tracker Research Group at Columbia University (2025). The State of Poverty and Disadvantage in New York City, Volume 7. Robin Hood.

 

[4] The Crisis in New York’s Family Courts (Feb. 2024), https://www.nysenate.gov/sites/default/files/admin/structure/media/manage/filefile/a/2024-02/2.12-family-court-hearing-report-w-graphics-1.pdf (All websites last accessed on March 27, 2025). The Chairs of the Children and Families and Judiciary Committees in both the Senate and the Assembly have endorsed these requests in their Call to Fully Fund New York’s Family Courts in the FY 2024-25 Budget, see https://www.nysenate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2024/brad-hoylman-sigal/legislators-legal-experts-and-advocates-call-fully. See also City Bar Testimony Presented at NYS Senate Children and Families and Judiciary Committees Joint Public Hearing on New York State Family Court (Nov. 1, 2023), https://www.nycbar.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/20221219_NYCBarAssnTestimonyNov1FCTHearing.pdf.

[5] County Law § 18-B provides for assignment of counsel to indigent litigants in both criminal and family court.  Judiciary Law § 35 provides for assignment of attorneys for children.

[6] See, 5 U.S. Code § 8146a