Comments Opposing Proposed Changes to the North Atlantic Right Whale Vessel Speed Rule
SUMMARY
The Animal Law Committee (Sherry Ramsey and Martha Golar, Co- Chairs) submitted a public comment opposing the proposed changes to the North Atlantic Right Whale Vessel Strike Reduction Rule. The Committee contends that the existing rule which requires large vessels to travel at ten knots or less in designated seasonal areas has reduced ship-strike mortality by approximately 90% and has been an essential conservation success. With fewer than 400 North Atlantic Right Whales remaining and ship strikes being a leading cause of death, the comment argues that protections should be expanded rather than rolled back. It also emphasizes the severe suffering whales endure from ship strikes, broader ecological benefits for other whale species migrating through New York waters, and the cultural significance of whales to Indigenous communities.
The Committee further argues that NOAA lacks sufficient evidence to justify weakening the rule and that alternative technologies cannot substitute for speed reductions. It also raises procedural and legal concerns, asserting that NOAA has failed to adequately consult Indigenous tribes and has not sufficiently complied with environmental review requirements under federal legislation. The Committee urges NOAA to preserve and strengthen the Vessel Speed Rule to prevent further whale deaths and reduce the risk of extinction.
REPORT
REPORT BY THE ANIMAL LAW COMMITTEE
COMMENTS IN OPPOSITION TO
ADVANCED NOTICE OF PROPOSED RULEMAKING TO AMEND THE NORTH ATLANTIC RIGHT WHALE VESSEL STRIKE REDUCTION RULE
50 CFR Part 224
DOCKET NO. 260227-0058
Federal Register Number 2026-04260
RIN 0648-BO42
The Animal Law Committee submits these comments in strong opposition to proposed changes to the North Atlantic Right Whale Vessel Strike Reduction Rule (hereafter Vessel Speed Rule or the Rule).[1] These proposed regulatory rollbacks would imperil whales by removing seasonal speed restrictions on large vessels.[2] By seasonally reducing the speeds of vessels 65 feet or longer to ten knots or less, the Rule has reduced ship strike mortality among North Atlantic Right Whales by approximately 90%.[3] Accordingly, the proposed rule change undermines, and likely will reverse, this proven progress. We believe the rule should be expanded and strengthened, not weakened.
Efforts to avoid ship strikes are especially critical for the North Atlantic Right Whale, which migrates through coastal New York waters.[4] There are fewer than 400 remaining North Atlantic Right Whales, and at least 142 have been killed or injured since 2017 alone, with a leading cause of death being ship strikes.[5] These deaths are preventable, and the Vessel Speed Rule is a crucial step towards saving the species, as well as protecting other marine life and boaters. Globally, 20,000 whales are killed by ship strikes each year, and New York’s coast is a critical migration corridor for many species.[6]
From an animal cruelty perspective, North Atlantic Right Whales who are struck by ships also suffer immensely. The force of ship strikes shatters bone and causes catastrophic soft tissue injuries as propellers slice through flesh.[7] Such suffering also disrupts the close-knit social structure of these magnificent animals.[8] For each of these reasons, we strongly support expanding and strengthening the Vessel Speed Rule.
I. THE NATIONAL OCEANIC AND ATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION (NOAA) DOES NOT HAVE SUFFICIENT EVIDENCE OF ALTERNATIVE CONSERVATION MEASURES TO WEAKEN THE VESSEL SPEED RULE
a. The Proposed Rule Does Not Adequately Consider the Broader Conservation Benefits of the Vessel Speed Rule
In addition to North Atlantic Right Whales, Blue Whales, Fin Whales, Sei Whales, Sperm Whales, and Humpback Whales migrating through the New York Bight have been identified as High Priority Species of Greatest Conservation Need under the New York State Wildlife Action Plan (SWAP).[9] These whales are also threatened by ship strikes, and can benefit from the Vessel Speed Rule.[10] Humpback whales, for instance, have such poor eyesight that they cannot see ships approaching.[11] They need conservation measures like the Vessel Speed Rule to protect them.
Although whales are also protected at the federal level by the Marine Mammal Protection Act (MMPA) and the Endangered Species Act (ESA), this protection is weakened by recent proposed changes to the ESA and MMPA.[12] We echo the concerns of other conservation organizations that weakening the Vessel Speed Rule may drive the North Atlantic Right Whale even closer to extinction, in addition to harming other marine life and undermining boater safety.[13] The Animal Law Committee respectfully urges NOAA not to weaken the Vessel Speed Rule, and to vigorously defend it in court.[14]
b. Monitoring is Not Sufficient to Replace Vessel Speed Reductions and Many Methods to Avoid Harm to Whales Exist But Are Underutilized
Currently, many methods exist to avoid death or harassment of whales yet are underutilized. Recent research, however, has found that most of these technologies have not yet been adopted at scale, and therefore cannot replace reducing vessel speeds.[15] For example, acoustic monitoring, better habitat mapping, thermal imaging, boat and aerial surveys, and satellite data all show promise to save whales by sending data to vessel owners on whales’ locations, but are imperfect and patchwork means of protection.[16] Ropeless traps with acoustic signals and breakaway fishing lines can also help prevent whales becoming tangled in fish nets, another leading cause of whale mortality, and should be further studied.[17] Although at times more costly than other equipment, educating vessel owners about the tremendous value of whales and risks to their survival could aid in encouraging adoption, but should not replace the Vessel Speed Rule.
Better imaging technology cannot wholly replace reducing vessel speed, analogous to how better x-rays do not repair or prevent broken bones.[18] In 2013, when removing the sunset provision of the Vessel Speed Rule, NOAA found that “[n]o known right whale deaths have occurred in speed restriction SMAs [Seasonal Management Areas] in the time since the restrictions were implemented.”[19] The Vessel Speed Rule is a tremendous conservation success and should be left intact, or even expanded to better protect North Atlantic Right Whales.
II. THE PROPOSED RULE DOES NOT ADEQUATELY CONSIDER INDIGENOUS RIGHTS OR ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS
a. NOAA Should Consult With Tribes
Although NOAA maintains a government-to-government consultation policy with Indigenous peoples, tribal consultation is not clearly outlined in the proposed rule.[20] In a past brief to the U.S. Supreme Court regarding offshore wind permitting, counsel for the Wampanoag identified NOAA’s lack of consultation as a violation of Executive Order 13175 and Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act.[21] The North Atlantic Right Whale has deep cultural significance to the Wampanoag, as well as to other Indigenous peoples.[22] Under federal law, not to mention NOAA’s own policies, tribal consultation is required.
b. NOAA Must Comply With the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and the Endangered Species Act (ESA)
In contrast to past proposed changes to the Vessel Speed Rule and other conservation measures protecting North Atlantic Right Whales, NOAA has not yet prepared a robust Environmental Assessment (EA) or Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), despite the significant environmental effects of the proposed rule as outlined above.[23] NOAA has previously stated that an EIS is required for the Right Whale Ship Strike Reduction Strategy, of which the Vessel Speed Rule is a critical part.[24] We believe that such an Environmental Assessment or a comprehensive EIS is necessary.
In addition to an EIS, the Endangered Species Act (ESA) – of which the Vessel Speed Rule is an implementing regulation – sets a high bar for protecting endangered species, and the Supreme Court has found that Congress intended for species survival to be prioritized.[25] Costs are not considered when species are listed, for instance, and listing decisions are based solely on the best scientific and commercial data available.[26] Although courts split on how precisely to evaluate economic costs at later stages of ESA enforcement, species survival is paramount.[27] Finally, even considering cost, costs to the shipping industry as a whole due to the Vessel Speed Rule are negligible.
III. THE PROPOSED RULE DOES NOT ADEQUATELY CONSIDER COSTS
a. Costs of the Vessel Speed Rule are Negligible to the Shipping Industry
Travelling more slowly helps boats preserve fuel and therefore can reduce costs. According to NOAA’s own reports, “fuel costs can make up a substantial proportion of a vessel’s operating costs and vessel fuel consumption generally increases exponentially with increasing speed.”[28] In addition to potentially reducing fuel costs, past estimates put the annual cost to industry of the Vessel Speed Rule at 0.005% of the trade value at ports covered by the rule.[29] Therefore, there is no merit to an argument that the shipping industry would enjoy relevant fuel cost savings by allowing the Vessel Speed Rule to sunset.
In contrast to such cost savings, vessels – especially small vessels – that strike whales may suffer catastrophic damage. In one notable ship strike that killed a North Atlantic Right Whale calf and severely injured the calf’s mother, the vessel was a total loss.[30] Safety considerations built into the Vessel Speed Rule benefit boaters as well as whales by limiting the chance of a catastrophic collision. Advocacy by sport fishing associations to weaken or rescind the Vessel Speed Rule largely overlooks these safety concerns.[31]
b. Economic Benefits of Whales are Not Adequately Considered
Nationwide, coastal tourism – including whale watching – contributes an estimated $143 billion to the U.S. economy, resulting in significant tourist revenue in New York state alone.[32] NOAA’s own economic studies have found that the American people are willing to pay $4.38 billion annually to save the North Atlantic Right Whale, far exceeding costs to the shipping industry.[33] Whales also sequester an average of 33 tons of carbon over their lifetime, helping to meet climate goals of the state(s). These climate and tourism benefits are not adequately considered by the proposed rule.[34] For each of these reasons – as well as their inherent value – whales deserve to be protected for future generations to marvel at and observe from a safe distance.
IV. CONCLUSION
The Animal Law Committee respectfully and urgently insists that NOAA preserve the North Atlantic Right Whale Vessel Strike Reduction Rule for our ocean neighbors. The Vessel Speed Rule is a key conservation measure to avoid the extinction of the North Atlantic Right Whale, as well as benefitting the marine eco-tourism industry and the shipping industry as a whole by maintaining key safety standards with negligible cost. We urge NOAA to not only maintain but expand the Vessel Speed Rule, as suggested by conservation experts and relevant research.[35]
Animal Law Committee
Sherry Ramsey, Co-Chair
Martha Golar, Co-Chair
Footnotes
[1] Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking To Amend the North Atlantic Right Whale Vessel Strike Reduction Rule, 91 Fed. Reg. 10580 (Mar. 4th, 2026).
[2] Id.
[3] P. B. Conn and G. K. Silber, Vessel speed restrictions reduce risk of collision-related mortality for North Atlantic right whales, Ecosphere (Apr. 3, 2013), https://doi.org/10.1890/ES13-00004.1. (All websites were last accessed May 29, 2026)
[4] Reducing Vessel Strikes to North Atlantic Right Whales, NOAA Fisheries (2026), https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/national/endangered-species-conservation/reducing-vessel-strikes-north-atlantic-right-whales.
[5] Saving the Endangered North Atlantic Right Whale, Whale and Dolphin Conservation, https://us.whales.org/whales-dolphins/how-we-help/saving-the-endangered-north-atlantic-right-whale/.
[6] Elena Gavigan, 20,000 Whales Are Killed by Ship Strikes Each Year, International Marine Mammal Project (Aug. 13, 2025), https://savedolphins.eii.org/news/20-000-whales-are-killed-by-ship-strikes-each-year and New York Bight Whale Monitoring Program, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, https://dec.ny.gov/nature/waterbodies/oceans-estuaries/bight-whale-monitoring-program.
[7] Right whale mother found dead last week suffered “catastrophic injuries” from vessel strike, NOAA announces, New England Aquarium (April 4, 2024), https://www.neaq.org/about-us/press-room/press-releases/right-whale-mother-suffered-catastrophic-injuries-from-vessel-strike/.
[8] Deep Dive: Right Whale Vessel Strikes, Whale and Dolphin Conservation, https://us.whales.org/deep-dive-right-whale-vessel-strikes/.
[9] New York Bight Whale Monitoring Program, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, https://dec.ny.gov/nature/waterbodies/oceans-estuaries/bight-whale-monitoring-program.
[10] Aaron Short, Whales Are in Danger in N.Y. Waterways: ‘Like Deer Crossing the Road’, New York Times (Jan. 3, 2026), https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/03/nyregion/new-york-whales-threat-waterways.html and Jessica V. Redfern et al., Estimating reductions in the risk of vessels striking whales achieved by management strategies, 290 Biological Conservation 110,427 (Feb. 2024), available at https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2023.110427.
[11] Id.
[12] Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972, 16 U.S.C. §§ 1361–1423h and Endangered Species Act of 1973, §§ 1531-1544. See also Trump Administration Proposes Fundamentally Weakening Endangered Species Act with Harmful New Rules, Sierra Club (Nov. 19, 2025), https://www.sierraclub.org/press-releases/2025/12/trump-administration-proposes-fundamentally-weakening-endangered-species-act and Ryan Green, The Law That Saved the Whales Is Under Attack, Scientific American (Aug. 6, 2025), https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/proposed-house-bill-would-weaken-marine-mammal-protection-act-endangering/.
[13] Michael Doyle, NOAA eyes ‘deregulatory’ rule for North Atlantic right whale, E&E News Politico (Feb. 12, 2026), https://www.eenews.net/articles/noaa-eyes-deregulatory-rule-for-north-atlantic-right-whale/ and Defenders Raises Alarm Over Administration’s Proposal to Amend Rule Protecting North Atlantic Right Whales From Deadly Vessel Strikes, Defenders of Wildlife (Feb. 12, 2026), https://defenders.org/newsroom/defenders-raises-alarm-over-administrations-proposal-amend-rule-protecting-north-atlantic See also Esther Lang, Slowing Down to Save the Right Whale: Why Stronger Vessel Speed Rules Still Matter, The Georgetown Environmental Law Review (Mar. 23, 2026), https://www.law.georgetown.edu/environmental-law-review/blog/slowing-down-to-save-the-right-whale-why-stronger-vessel-speed-rules-still-matter/ and Save the Vessel Speed Rule, Whale and Dolphin Conservation (2026), https://us.whales.org/policy/save-the-vessel-speed-rule/.
[14] See Urbinati, Jr. v. Lutnick et al. and Laura Sheehan et al., Legal Intervention Aims to Protect North Atlantic Right Whales From Deadly Ship Strikes, Center for Biological Diversity (May 11, 2026), https://biologicaldiversity.org/w/news/press-releases/legal-intervention-aims-to-protect-north-atlantic-right-whales-from-deadly-ship-strikes-2026-05-11/.
[15] Casey Corrado Kirsch, Dr. Tom Weber, and Dr. Matt Adams, Technology Readiness Levels (TRL) for North Atlantic Right Whale Detection and Vessel Strike Risk Reduction (November 2025), https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/s3/2026-02/Vessel-Strike-Risk-Reduction-TRLReport.pdf.
[16] Elena Gavigan, 20,000 Whales Are Killed by Ship Strikes Each Year, International Marine Mammal Project (Aug. 13, 2025), https://savedolphins.eii.org/news/20-000-whales-are-killed-by-ship-strikes-each-year and Save the Vessel Speed Rule, Whale and Dolphin Conservation (2026), https://us.whales.org/policy/save-the-vessel-speed-rule/.
[17] Aaron Short, Whales Are in Danger in N.Y. Waterways: ‘Like Deer Crossing the Road’, New York Times (Jan. 3, 2026), https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/03/nyregion/new-york-whales-threat-waterways.html.
[18] Whale and Dolphin Conservation’s Vessel Speed Rule Webinar used a similar metaphor of x-rays not treating cavities, highlighting the degree to which the Vessel Speed Rule is supported by conservation experts.
[19] Endangered Fish and Wildlife; Final Rule To Remove the Sunset Provision of the Final Rule Implementing Vessel Speed Restrictions To Reduce the Threat of Ship Collisions With North Atlantic Right Whales, 78 Fed. Reg. 73,726 (Dec. 9, 2013).
[20] NOAA Procedures for Government-to-Government Consultation with Federally Recognized Indian Tribal Governments, NOAA (June 2023), https://www.noaa.gov/sites/default/files/2023-07/NOAA_Tribal_Consultation_Handbook_2023_FINAL.pdf.
[21] Brief of Petitioners at 4, Nantucket Residents Against Turbines et al. v. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management et al., No. 24-337 (U.S. 2024), available at https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/24/24-337/330301/20241025143716219_2024-10-25-ECF%2024-337%20Amicus%20Brief.pdf.
[22] Id. at 3-4.
[23] Endangered Fish and Wildlife; National Environmental Policy Act; Right Whale Ship Strike Reduction Strategy Notice of Intent to Prepare an Environmental Impact Statement and Conduct Public Scoping, 70 Fed. Reg. 36,121 (June 22, 2005) and Draft Environmental Assessment for Amendments to the North Atlantic Right Whale Vessel Strike Reduction Rule, NOAA (July 2022), https://media.fisheries.noaa.gov/2022-07/NARW_Proposed_Speed_Rule_Draft_EA_508_0.pdf.
[24] Endangered Fish and Wildlife; National Environmental Policy Act; Right Whale Ship Strike Reduction Strategy Notice of Intent to Prepare an Environmental Impact Statement and Conduct Public Scoping, 70 Fed. Reg. 36,121 (June 22, 2005) quoting Council on Environmental Quality’s Regulations at 40 CFR parts 1500, 1508, and NOAA’s procedures for implementing NEPA found in NOAA Administrative Order (NAO) 216-6, Environmental Policy Act, dated May 20, 1999.
[25] Esther Lang, Slowing Down to Save the Right Whale: Why Stronger Vessel Speed Rules Still Matter, The Georgetown Environmental Law Review (Mar. 23, 2026), https://www.law.georgetown.edu/environmental-law-review/blog/slowing-down-to-save-the-right-whale-why-stronger-vessel-speed-rules-still-matter/ citing Tenn. Valley Auth. v. Hill, 437 U.S. 153, 184 (1978)
[26] ESA § 4(b)(1)(A), 16 U.S.C. § 1533(b)(1)(A)
[27] Amy Sinder, The Economics of Endangered Species: Why Less is More in the Economic Analysis of Critical Habitat Designations, 28 Harv. Envtl. L. Rev. 129 (2004) and Sheila Baynes, Cost Consideration and the Endangered Species Act, 90(3) New York Uni. L. Rev. 961 (2015).
[28] North Atlantic Right Whale (Eubalaena glacialis) Vessel Speed Rule Assessment, NOAA Fisheries Office of Protected Resources (June 2020) at 29, available at https://media.fisheries.noaa.gov/2021-01/FINAL_NARW_Vessel_Speed_Rule_Report_Jun_2020.pdf.
[29] Id. at 30.
[30] Greg Reilly, Slow down to save endangered North Atlantic right whales, IFAW (Aug. 8, 2023), https://www.ifaw.org/journal/slow-down-to-save-endangered-north-atlantic-right-whales.
[31] Jack Vitek, Time to Act on Vessel Speed Rule, Again, Marlin Magazine (May 20, 2026), https://www.marlinmag.com/advocacy/noaa-vessel-speed-rule-2026-update/.
[32] The Value of Marine Mammals, Marine Mammal Commission, https://www.mmc.gov/priority-topics/value-marine-mammals/.
[33] Protected Species Economics Research, NOAA Fisheries (Feb. 24, 2020), https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/national/socioeconomics/protected-species-economics-research
[34] Whales and Carbon Sequestration: Can Whales Store Carbon?, NOAA Fisheries (Feb. 13, 2024.), https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/feature-story/whales-and-carbon-sequestration-can-whales-store-carbon.
[35] Jessica V. Redfern et al., Estimating reductions in the risk of vessels striking whales achieved by management strategies, 290 Biological Conservation 110,427 (Feb. 2024), available at https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2023.110427.