Committee Reports

Comments on a proposal to adding a new rule in regard to the filing of amicus briefs

SUMMARY

The New York City Bar Association’s Council on Judicial Administration, State Courts of Superior Jurisdiction Committee, and Litigation Committee submitted comments to the Office of Court Administration in response to a request for public comment on a proposal to add a new Rule 23 to the Rules of the Commercial Division regarding the filing of amicus briefs. The Committees do not support the proposed rule for two primary reasons. First, there is not a material need for amicus briefs at the trial level. The addition of such a rule may promote the filing of unnecessary motions, drain judicial resources, and increase costs for litigants. Second, parties are free to move for leave to file amicus briefs without a rule expressly permitting it. If the circumstances truly require an amicus brief at the trial level, a motion can be made even without the rule.

REPORT

By Email

David Nocenti, Esq.
Office of Court Administration
25 Beaver Street, 10th Floor
New York, NY 10004
rulecomments@nycourts.gov

Re: New York City Bar Association Response to Request for Public Comment on a proposal to add a new Rule 23 to the Rules of the Commercial Division regarding the filing of amicus briefs

Dear Mr. Nocenti:

We write to provide comments with respect to the Request for Public Comment on a proposal to add a new Rule 23 to the Rules of the Commercial Division regarding the filing of amicus briefs.

The New York City Bar Association’s Council on Judicial Administration, State Courts of Superior Jurisdiction Committee, and Litigation Committee (the “Committees” have considered and discussed the proposed rule change. The Committees do not support the proposed rule, for two primary reasons. First, members of the committees do not feel that there is a material need for amicus briefs at the trial level. The addition of such a rule may promote the filing of unnecessary motions, drain judicial resources, and increase costs for litigants. Second, it appears that parties are free to move for leave to file amicus briefs without a rule expressly permitting it. If the circumstances truly require an amicus brief at the trial level, a motion can be made even without the rule.

Thank you for considering our comments. If you believe that it would be beneficial, we would be happy to discuss these comments with you further.

Sincerely,

Fran Hoffinger, Chair
Council on Judicial Administration

Cassandra Porsch, Chair
Litigation Committee

Amy D. Carlin, Chair
State Courts of Superior Jurisdiction